24 May 2016

The Buzz on the History of the Binder Beekeeping Ranch of Soquel Canyon

Soquel Canyon, Carbon Canyon's southern neighbor, is, compared to others in the area, relatively undisturbed.  There are remnants of structures in Hidden Valley, the area where the Chino Ranch Ride (covered here in a recent post) took place for decades from the late 1930s.  On the eastern end, the Aerojet munitions testing facility has certainly left a mark below ground level, though much of the physical presence above ground is absent.  Much of the canyon is held as private property, but development of any kind is going to be problematic given the difficulty of access.

This situation is not for a lack of trying, however.  As early as the mid-1920s, a proposal, noted here previously, to build a road through Soquel from Brea to Chino was floated and the idea remained in the minds of regional and local planners and others (and may still for some).  In the late 1960s, traffic studies, noting that the 91, 60 and soon-to-be opened 57 freeways and Carbon Canyon Road (Grand Avenue was years from being pushed through to Chino Hills) were the only east-west corridors between the Inland Empire and Orange County, advocated fora 6-lane highway through Soquel that would have destroyed it.  Finally, not that many years ago, the highway concept was dropped, though no one should be surprised if an attempt to reintroduce the idea will come once again.

In its early days, uses of Soquel Canyon were few.  The eastern portion falls within the boundaries of the Rancho Santa Ana del Chino and was used for grazing cattle and other animals on the property.  To the west, a section of Soquel was within public lands that were common areas for owners of ranchos, such as Chino, to use when their properties were over-grazed or threatened to become so.

With the gradual demise of the rancho system, though, public lands were made available for sale, starting in the later 1860s.  It appears that one of the first persons to take the opportunity to acquire property in the public portion of Soquel Canyon was Charles Binder.

Binder was born in 1840 in Copenhagen, Denmark and immigrated to the United States, where he worked as a carpenter and then joined the Army at Wilkes-Barre, Pennsylvania in June 1872.  By the end of the year, though, Binder decided the military wasn't for him and, in what was a common act at the time, deserted his unit.  It appears that, not long after, he drifted westward.

Charles Binder's voter registration record from 1879, showing his naturalization the previous fall in Los Angeles and identifying him as a beekeeper in the Anaheim township--specifically at Soquel Canyon.
By the late 1870s, he was in the Los Angeles area, where he was naturalized in November 1878.  The following summer, in July 1879, he registered to vote as a resident of Anaheim Township and was listed as a 39-year old bee rancher.  Though it was not stated, Binder had established himself in Soquel Canyon to do his work, though it appears that he did not keep his residence at the ranch, but lived elsewhere in the area.

At the end of June 1880, enumerator J.W. Anderson made his way through the Orange-Santa Ana Township of Los Angeles County as part of the undertaking of the federal census.  After leaving Santa Ana Canyon and the home of Marcos Yorba, son of prominent ranchero Bernardo Yorba, in what is now Yorba Linda, Anderson headed northwest.

Charles Binder's 1880 census listing showing him as an apiarist in Soquel Canyon within the Orange Santa Ana Township.  He also appears to have been bee-keeping near modern Claremont at the same time.
He came across two 40-year old Danes, Christian Christensen and Binder, both of whom were listed as being an "apariast," the proprietor of a bee-keeping enterprise.  Binder had a German-Mexican employee, Anton Smith, as an employee.  Two households down was Alfred Patten, a 26-year old native of Arkansas, who also was practicing the apiary trade.  Then, the next two households featured Claus Grim, a 35-year old German, and 27-year old Frank M. Davis, also from Arkansas, both of whom were listed as working with "Cattle & Bees."

This stereoscopic photograph of a San Gabriel Valley apiary, or bee keeping ranch, was taken by A. C. Varela about 1878, which is roughly when Charles Binder began his bee-keeping work at Soquel Canyon.  Photo courtesy of the Workman and Temple Family Homestead Museum, City of Industry.
There was, in fact, in the 1870s and 1880s, a bit of a bee-keeping craze in the greater Los Angeles area, with apiarists setting up their facilities in the San Gabriel Valley and, apparently, in what later became northeastern Orange County.

On the same 1880 census, but in the San Jose township, north of Pomona, there was a listing by census taker Frank Ellis, for 40-year old Charles Binder, "apiarian" and a 30-year old man, known only as "John Doe."  Though Binder was listed here as hailing from Germany, it seems certain that he had two separate bee-keeping facilities--one at Soquel Canyon and the other probably in the vicinity of San Antonio Canyon near what is now Claremont, given that his near neighbor was the Reverend Charles F. Loop, co-owner of the Loop and Meserve Tract that encompased the area.

Charles Binder's listing as an apiarian in the San Jose & Azusa township, specifically near San Antonio Canyon in modern Claremont, 1880 Federal Census.
In 1882, Binder was listed in a newspaper public notice as having "possession, interest and claim to 160 acres, being southeast quarter of section 31 township 2 south range 9 west."  This looks to be an area up near Brea Canyon, which might be an indication of his trying to expand his land-holding interests. Two years later, Binder was listed as a bee-keeper in the Anaheim section of the Los Angeles City and County Directory.

On 20 August 1888, two notable events happened for Binder. First, he re-registered to vote, once again listing himself as a beekeeper in Anaheim.  The second is that the 48-year old was married in East Los Angeles (now the Lincoln Heights neighborhood of Los Angeles) to Celia Clarkston, also of Anaheim and also 48-years old.

From the Los Angeles Herald of 28 July 1889 is a brief description of a wildfire that burned Charles Binder's apiary--this may be the first documented Carbon Canyon area wildfire.
Tragedy struck just under a year later.  In what may be the earliest documented wildfire in the Carbon Canyon area, the Los Angeles Herald of 27 July 1889 had a brief article reporting that,
Fire on the Olinda Ranch, north of Anaheim, last evening swept over a vast amount of territory, destroying Charles Binder's bee ranch, windmill, barn and other property.  The fire started from brush burning, which got beyond control.  Loss several thousand dollars.
As chronicled here before, the Shanklin Ranch, which covered several thousand acres of the area, mainly became the property of W.H. Bailey, a native of Maui, Hawaii, who renamed his property Olinda after his family's plantation on the Hawaiian island.  Whether Binder's ranch was actually on the ranch and had been purchased or leased by him is not clear.

Another major issue was the state of the local economy.  The well-known "Boom of the Eighties" which peaked in 1887-88 and which, at Olinda Ranch, led to grand plans like the town of Carlton and a proposed railroad from Chino, went bust about the time of the fire that destroyed Binder's apiary.

The 1890s was a decade in which the Los Angeles region was frequently in drought conditions and the nation was hit by a debilitating depression in 1893.  Still, Binder persevered with his bee-keeping enterprise.  In the 5 November 1893 issue of the Herald it was reported that "Charles Binder of Anaheim has purchased the cottage of W.T. Smith and moved his family out to Mr. Binder's foothill ranch."  This "foothill ranch" is almost certainly his apiary at Soquel Canyon.

Binder's stay at the "foothill ranch" appears to have been limited, however.  Whereas in 1892 he registered to vote out of the Yorba precinct with an Anaheim post office address, four years later, he registered out of Fullerton and gave his occupation as a farmer.

This appears to correspond with his purchase of three lots in the town in March 1895 from the Pacific Land Improvement Company, which was a subsidiary of the Atchison, Topeka and Santa Fe Railroad, the line of which passed along the south edge of the town and whose president was George H. Fullerton, its namesake.  Pacific Land was also the founder of Claremont, another town along a Santa Fe line and owned the land on behalf of the Santa Fe in the Olinda oil field, where the railroad's Petroleum Development Company operated the earliest wells.

The "Death Record" listings from the Los Angeles Times, 22 May 1899, including one for the death of Charles Binder the prior day at his Fullerton home.
On 21 May 1899, Binder died at his Fullerton home at the age of 59 or 60 and his widow, Celia, continued to reside there.  In 1900, she leased out the Binder Ranch to the newly formed Soquel Canyon Oil Company.  A July 1900 issue of the Los Angeles-based magazine The Capital featured an article on local oil companies, including the Carbon Canyon Oil Company (covered here previously) and Soquel Canyon Oil, described as having 190 acres under its ownership just east of Olinda.

While it would be expected that articles like this would play up the potential of oil-bearing lands like that of Soquel Canyon oil, it is also not surprising that, far more often than not, small players like the firm quickly revealed the risky nature of the business.

The first well proved to be dry of oil, if not of water and, as reported in the Herald twice in mid-March 1901, it was abandoned.  Another well was sited, but proved to be problematic, as well.  A year later, the company pulled out its rigging and transferred to a well it was working on in the Los Angeles field near downtown.

A Herald piece from 1 May also observed that there were many rumors of gold in the Soquel Canyon area, with one canyon going by the name of "Robbers' Roost Canyon."  While stating that there were indications of quartz and iron in the hills, there was also reference to the allegations that "a few years ago there was some excitement over the alleged discovery of coal on the Binder ranch, but this fund did not prove profitable.  As early as 1877, maps showed a number of coal mining claims in the area, which is almost certainly how Carbon Canyon got its name.

Speaking of maps, the Soquel Canyon Oil Company had its two wells in the area where Soquel and Carbon canyons meet, right at the location of today's Olinda Village and Hollydale Mobile Home Estates.  It may be that the Binder ranch was situated on land that later was partially or completely purchased by Edward Gaines and which became the "Flying Cow Ranch".

Several years ago, apiaries were noticed at the west end of the La Vida Mineral Springs property, though that material was soon removed.  Other boxes for bee keeping have been spotted on hilltops between Carbon and Soquel canyons and some are still there, though inactive.  It is almost certainly unlikely that these modern apiarians were aware of the history of bee keeping in our local canyons dating back to the 1870s.  Given the severe threat to bees now, apparently due to pesticides, it may be that a new era of apiaries is long overdue. 

08 May 2016

Carbon Canyon Historic Artifact #51: Joseph Bridger Adobe at Los Serranos Country Club

In 1865, when Robert Carlisle, the hot-headed husband of Francisca Williams, who inherited Rancho Santa Ana del Chino from her father, Isaac Williams, upon his death in 1856, was killed in a famous shootout at the Bella Union Hotel in Los Angeles, the ranch became supervised by trustees, principally Los Angeles banker Isaias W. Hellman (as recently covered here in this blog) on behalf of Francisca and her children with Carlisle.

Hired to manage the ranch was Joseph Bridger, born in Tenneessee in 1830, and who married one of Isaac Williams' daughters from an Indan wife, the daughter of Chief Pablo Apis of Temecula.  While some sources state that Bridger bought the Chino Ranch from Francisca Williams Carlisle, that is not the case.

For example, journalist Benjamin C. Truman's 1874 book Semi-Tropical California, states very clearly that
The property of the heirs of Robert Carlisle deceased it is managed and supervised by Mr Joseph Bridger and it was from his hospitable residence that I sallied out upon the several tours which I made through its broad acres
Francisca Carlisle married Frederick A. MacDougall, a mayor of Los Angeles in the late 1870s, and moved to Los Angeles with her children, leaving Chino in the very capable hands of her half brother-in-law Bridger.

A real photo postcard, dated 1 February 1927, of the "Home Ranch" adobe house on the Rancho Santa Ana del Chino, built by Joseph Bridger after 1865, used by Richard Gird after 1881 and then, from 1924, serving as the clubhouse for Los Serranos Country Club, until it was razed.  The site is now the current clubhouse, opened in 1995.  
Note that Truman stated that he toured the massive ranch with Bridger "from his hospitable residence."  Eventually, this became known as the "Home Ranch" and another confusion about the history of the Rancho Santa Ana del Chino is that this was also the original ranch home of Antonio María Lugo, grantee of the ranch in 1841, as well as Isaac Williams, who was given control of the domain.

Yet, in 1938, Bridger's son Andrew and the Carlisle's two surviving daughters, Mary and Laura, provided a statement clarifying the situation, observing that the original Chino ranch house was:
upon the site of the former main building (pink house, as its color designated) at what is now known as the George Junior Republic dairy—an adobe, the headquarters of Mr. H. J. Stewart, 1874—since then destroyed, we understand, by fire and demolition.
This "former main building" of the "George Junior Republic dairy" is the site of today's Boys Republic facility in Chino Hills, a couple of miles north of the "Home Ranch" adobe house Bridger built after 1865.  It should be noted that a California State Historic Landmark plaque commemorating the 1846 Battle of Chino, which took place at the original adobe of Lugo and Williams, stands at the Chino Valley Independent Fire District training building (a former fire station) just outside the Boys Republic complex on Eucalyptus Avenue, just northwest of the intersection of Pipeline Avenue.

Traveling south on Pipeline today gets you to the western boundary of Los Serranos Country Club.  After Joseph Bridger's sudden death on 23 September 1880, it was decided to sell the Rancho Santa Ana del Chino, the buyer being Tombstone, Arizona mining magnate Richard Gird.

Gird moved into the Bridger adobe and significantly added and improved it, turning the structure into a showplace for his magnificent domain.  After Gird lost control of the ranch and it moved through several owners, eventually falling into the hands of oilman E.J. Marshall, the adobe stayed intact.

Finally, in 1924, the Campbell-Joralmon real estate firm, working with the Marshall Estate, sold the Bridger-Gird "Home Ranch" adobe and surrounding land to a syndicate of Long Beach investors who established the Los Serranos Country Club and Los Serranos subdivision.

The connection to Carbon Canyon is that the owners of the new country club actively promoted improvements to Carbon Canyon Road, because it provided a shorter route to the facility from Los Angeles.  A complete paving of the road was completed by the end of 1920s, a few years before it became part of the California state highway system.

The real photo postcard shown here is of the adobe and is titled "Los Serranos C. Club / Club House."  On the back of the unused card, is a pencil inscription with the date 1 February 1927, less than two years after the golf club opened to the public.

The image shows much of the two-story structure, with a broad balcony along its length, largely obscured by palm and other trees, as well as tall hedges.  In the foreground is a large open lawn with wood chairs scattered about it.

The old adobe and clubhouse are long gone now and the site is the location of the current clubhouse, which opened in 1995.

04 May 2016

Another Carbon Canyon Road Closure

UPDATE, 4:48 p.m.:  Well, there was a change in plans, as posted by the City of Chino Hills:
Wed., 5/4, 4:40 pm - Carbon Canyon Road is now open. AT&T did a temporary fix. Additional repairs will be done at a later time
UPDATE, 4:33 p.m.:  The latest from the City of Chino Hills also estimates an 8 p.m. reopening:

Wed., May 4th - Carbon Canyon Road is Closed Through Evening Commute Hours

Wednesday, May 4th; 4:30 pm - Carbon Canyon Road is completely closed in both directions between Olinda Village and Sleepy Hollow due to downed phone lines. Motorists should plan an alternate route as repairs will continue through the evening commute hours. Chino Hills residents can get to their homes from the Chino Hills side; and Brea residents can get home from the Brea side. Estimated completion of repairs is 8:00 pm. Once word is received that Carbon Canyon has reopened, this message will be updated. 
UPDATE, 4 p.m.:  It looks like Carbon Canyon Road may be open by 8 p.m. tonight, according to the Orange County Register:
A downed telephone line prompted authorities to close off a portion of Carbon Canyon Road in Brea Wednesday afternoon.
Brea police were called around 12 p.m. about an AT&T line in the road, said Lt. Bill Smyser.
Authorities closed the road from Olinda Village to the San Bernardino County line. Residents can still access their homes, Symser said.
No one was reported injured.
Crews are working to repair the line, and the road is expected to reopened by 8 p.m.
It's become a common occurrence over the years--Carbon Canyon Road has been closed, for about the last 45 minutes, because of a car accident leading to downed power lines on the Brea side of the canyon.

Here is the information from the City of Chino Hills:

Carbon Canyon Road is Closed Due to Downed Power Lines

Carbon Canyon Road is closed at this time due to downed power lines as a result of a traffic accident. The closure is from Olinda to the County line. Residents can get home to as far as Sleepy Hollow, but no through traffic is being allowed.

There is currently no estimated time for the reopening of the road.
This is from a post on the NextDoor Sleepy Hollow neighborhood page from 9 April.
This follows another recent closure of a couple of weeks ago due to a wreck on the S-curve in the Chino Hills portion.  Before that, there was a post on the Sleepy Hollow community page of NextDoor showing an overturned vehicle resting against an embankment along the eastbound side of the state highway just east of Old Carbon Canyon Road.

More recently, within the last several days, that poor sign on the S-curve eastbound at the first tight curve, which has been flattened, battered and beaten many times, has had a partial amputation of its left leg due to an errant driver.

24 April 2016

Carbon Canyon Fire Safe Council Brush Drop Off A Success

Yesterday's Brush Drop Off program, coordinated by the Carbon Canyon Fire Safe Council, went great.

From 8 a.m. until about Noon, a few Council volunteers assisted residents from the Chino Hills portion of the canyon, in unloading and filling a 40-foot long roll-off bin of all kinds of cut material, from brush to tree limbs and other items.

This program is made possible with funding from the City of Chino Hills and the bin dropped off and picked up by Chino Hills Disposal, as well as the coordination of Council chairperson Charlie Blank.

The haul was pretty impressive--somewhere from 7,000 to 8,000 pounds of flammable plant material was removed from the canyon.

With yet another dry winter in our region portending what will almost certainly be a high risk for wildfires this summer and fall, anything we can do to mitigate that risk in the way of brush removal becomes that much more important.

So, thanks to the Carbon Canyon Fire Safe Council, the City of Chino Hills, Chino Hills Disposal, and participating residents for the collaborative effort on reducing wildfire risk in our canyon!

21 April 2016

Hills for Everyone Fundraiser in Carbon Canyon on 30 April

On Saturday, 30 April from 4 to 7:30 p.m., Hills for Everyone, the organization that has been leading the fight to preserve habitat and open space in Carbon Canyon and nearby areas and heading the legal battle against the proposed Madrona project of 162 houses in the canyon, is holding a fundraiser to continue that court fight.

The venue is the hilltop home of Andy and Jolene Grinstead in Carbon Canyon, where their new 5,400-square foot residence, spacious property on 33 acres and stunning views will be among the attractions at the event.  In addition, there will be a presentation by falconer Joy Roy III of Aerial Predators featuring several birds of prey, house tours and a silent auction.

Tickets are $100 per person with 85% of that going towards the continuing effort to stave off the State of Idaho's appeal on Madrona (the remainder covers the food and drinks.)

There are no at-the-door (or at-the-driveway) tickets, so the only way to attend this event is by purchasing in advance over at the HEF website, using PayPal,

Click here for more information and to make your reservations for this unique and special event!

16 April 2016

Carbon Canyon Brush Drop-Off Day Next Saturday!

The Carbon Canyon Fire Safe Council's annual spring brush drop-off day is next Saturday the 23rd from 8 a.m. to 1 p.m.  Carbon Canyon residents in the Chino Hills portion only can bring cut brush to the drop-off location next to Fire Station 64 on Canon Lane just north of Carbon Canyon Road.

Thanks to the City of Chino Hills and Chino Hills Disposal, who are paying for and providing a roll-off bin, the brush can be deposited at the site for Chino Hills Disposal to haul away.  Fire Safe Council volunteers will be present to assist.

Property inspections by the Chino Valley Independent Fire District are underway and there is a 15 May deadline for canyon residents to cut brush and remove other material that can be a fire risk and the drop-off is one way to dispose of these items--the other, of course, being the trash cans provided by the disposal company.  But, for larger quantities of brush, this is the way to go.

09 April 2016

Soquel Canyon: A Murderer's Hideout 150 Years Ago

On 17 September 1854, on what is now Valley Boulevard in the City of Industry, but at that time generally known as the "Colorado Road" or "Valley Road" on the portion owned by rancher William Workman on the massive Rancho La Puente, according to the Los Angeles Star newspaper, "a horrid murder was consummated by three fiends in human shape."

James Ellington, who had recently moved to the community of El Monte, settled three years before by emigrants from the American South, and who lived on the east side of the San Gabriel River (at that time flowing in the channel now called the Rio Hondo), was out "to hunt some of his stock" which had wandered loose.  Later that afternoon, a young man looking for cattle, "found Mr. Ellinton lying on the ground wounded, and, as he supposed, nearly dead."

After help was summoned it was determined that Ellington was, after all, "perfectly dead."  The county coroner was not available because he was holding an inquest up at Tejon in the northern extremes of the county, so a Los Angeles doctor, Henry Myles, was brought out from a religious camp meeting in El Monte to hold the inquest, with six local residents serving as jurors.  It was determined that Ellington had been pierced "with fourteen wounds on his body, made by some sharp instrument like a sword or lance."

Myles reported that Ellington's revolver, some $300, and his hat were taken and a good deal of time was spent describing the latter, because it appeared one of the killers took it and left their own "very mean one, apparently belonging to an Indian, or low Sonorian—we hardly believe a Californians in the county could be found with a hat of similar quality," as described by the Star.  The insinuation clearly was that the murderer would be found with a fancy Parisian hat at odds with his "low" appearance as an Indian or Mexican.

The Los Angeles Southern Californian report on the murder of El Monte resident James Ellington, 21 September 1854.
The Southern Californian, Los Angeles' other weekly paper, issued its report, adding that Ellington was evidently first attacked about a half a mile from his house and then chased about that distance further east.  It repeated other of the details found in the Star, including the fact that one of the killers must have been "an Indian or some low Mexican."

The paper did add some details about the scene of Ellington's death and the evidence noted there, as well as the fact that "Californians and Sonorians were in the habit of coming about his house, and as he generally carried the above amount of money about him, in his purse, it is probable that the fact may have been noticed by them."  It also added that Ellington had planned on going to the same camp meeting where Myles was when called to conduct the inquest.

The following day, the 18th, a pig herder, Charles Moore, on the Rancho Santa Gertrudes, owned by Lemuel Carpenter, where La Mirada, Santa Fe Springs and other modern communities are now, repoted that "he was accosted by two Mexicans or Sonorians, and a boy, in a friendly manner, who asked Moore for some whiskey," as reported by the Star.  They also asked for a match and some string and, while one was cutting the latter, he struck out at Moore, hitting his hand as he raised it in defense.  Moore than jumped from his horse and ran "one of them firing four shots at him as he ran."

Moore noted that "they were armed with one six shooter and a large bowie knife with a black handle."  In addition, he continued, "one of these men wore a black fur hat, corresponding in size and shape to the one Ellington wore when he was assassinated the day previous."  Consequently, about ten men headed out to track down these three persons on Tuesday the 19th.

On 12 October, the county Grand Jury submitted its report, noting that there were five criminal cases it examined, but that "upon an investigation of the circumstances relative to the murder of James Ellington, there was no sufficient testimony to attach culpability to any person."  This was because the killers were still at large, nearly a month after the killing.

The next day, the 13th, Pinckney Clifford was murdered at a Los Angeles livery stable where he worked by David Brown, a former deputy constable as well as a petty criminal with a sordid history from his days in Texas and elsewhere in the West, who stabbed Clifford during an argument and was promptly apprehended, jailed and then examined by the town's justice of the peace.

On the 14th, a public meeting was held at the county court house and it was determined that, the law being ineffective, citizens should take the matter into their own hands, as had been done several times before, and exact justice on Brown.

After a quick "popular tribunal," at which it was determined that Brown was guilty, Los Angeles mayor Stephen C. Foster "appeared and wishes to be heard for one moment,  He mounted the table  . . . and [said] he was anxious, and he oped the people would be so too, to give them [the courts] one more chance at the speedy administration of the law."

Moreover, Foster promised the assembly that "in the event of the prsoner escaping by any quibbles or ticks, he would at once resign his office and be the first to go and inflict summary punishment upon Brown."  These words proved effective, as the group decided to follow Foster's recommendations.

The arrest of Felipe Alvtire and an Indian woman "in the hills between the Coyote and Chino Ranchos" as covered in the Los Angeles Southern Californian, 2 November 1854.
On 26 September, Ignacio Palomares, co-owner of the Rancho San José, comprising modern Pomona and surrounding areas, rode into Los Angeles with two prisoners, a man and a woman, who he captured "in the hills between the Coyote and Chino Ranchos."  The last two places were the Rancho Los Coyotes, today's La Habra and Fullerton areas, and the Rancho Santa Ana del Chino, which comprises Chino and Chino Hills, including part of Carbon Canyon.

Palomares, as reported in the Southern Californian on 2 November, stated that he "was out hunting some stolen horses of his, [and] encountered in the hills two horses, saddled; and in search the cause of their being there, he discovered" the man and woman, the latter "dressed in male attire."  The two tried to flee by "runing over the hill—immediately pursuit being made, they stopped."

The man, who gave his name as Felipe Alvitre, whose father was one of the early Spanish soldiers in California and whose family lived in Misión Vieja or the old Mission San Gabriel location in Whittier Narrows, near El Monte, handed over a revolver and a knife.  Alvitre also stated "that he was hiding on account of crimes which he had committed," including the killing of Ellington and the murder of a Chilean near the Rancho Coyotes and that a brother and an Indian were with him at both homicides.

When questioned further about the Ellington homicide, "Alvitre, in giving his reason for killing Ellington, said he 'thought he might as well kill him as not'."  As for the unnamed Chilean, it was "for some sharp answer made to him on the road."

Notably, the Southern Californian did not identify the specific location of the capture of Alvitre and the woman, but did report on the attempts of county jailer Francis Carpenter and a posse who were searching for Alvitre and "thoroughly examined the Canada of Santiago, (one of the principal lairs of the outlaws), but could discover nothing," though Carpenter identified Santiago Canyon east of Orange, as "on of the wildest of places, and affording the most complete faculties for security of any spot he has ever visited."

That paper did say "there are many other fortresses equally as well calculated to receive fugitives from justice, in which they can take refuge until such time as the coast becomes clearer".

The Star had an account of the capture with different detail.  For example it stated that the Indian girl found with Alvitre was named Inocencia (she was soon released from custody as having no involvement in the crimes) and that Alvitre's brother, Jose, a Mexican from Sonora named Martín and a 14-year old Indian named Miguel, who was employed by William Workman at Rancho La Puente were the others involved in the murders of Ellington and the Chilean, who the Star identified as Gorgonio Carrera.  The Alvitre brothers and Miguel were involved in Ellington's murder, while Martín joined them when Carrera was killed on the road from Los Coyotes to the house of Domingo Yorba in what is now Santa Ana.

As to Alvitre's capture, Palomares was joined by Ramon Ybarra, whose family owned Rancho Cañada de la Brea (Brea Canyon), Inocente Valdez and others.  More interestingly, the location where the arrest was made was given as "Cañada del Saucal" otherwise known as Soquel Canyon.

The Los Angeles Star's coverage of the execution of Felipe Alvitre, 18 January 1855.
After his capture, Alvitre was tried and convicted in the District Court in Los Angeles and Judge Benjmain Hayes sentenced him to be hung on 12 January 1855, along with David Brown, who was convicted at the same term of the court.  When Brown's attorneys were able to secure from the state supreme court a stay in the execution pending an appeal on the grounds of an impartial trial (after all, the mayor of Los Angeles threatened to resign and lead a lynching!), Alvitre's petition to the supreme court was, according to Judge Hayes, misdelivered.

Consequently, when the day of execution arrived, Alvitre was hung as the sentence dictated.  Enraged crowds gathered at the jail demanded that Brown be taken out and lynched.  Sure enough, Stephen Foster arrived, promptly resigned as mayor, and joined the mob that stormed the jail, seized Brown and hung him just a short time after Alvitre.  Incidentally, when a special election was held just after the episode, Foster was elected back to his office!

A recent post on this blog on the Chino Ranch Ride, held in Soquel Canyon from the 1930s to the 1980s, featured an early program that provided a fancilful history including the assertion that the canyon was a hideout for the legendary Joaquin Murrieta, who was said to have killed in 1853.  Though it is doubtful that writers of the program knew about Felipe Alvitre and his hideout in Soquel Canyon the year after Murrieta's demise, the assumption makes sense.

Soquel Canyon is often narrow and can be filled with plant life along its creek during wet years and it obviously served as an excellent hiding place for Alvitre and his female companion for almost a month in September and October 1854.